top of page

Body and Soul (1947)

Steve Hunt
2 days ago
4 min read

I recently had the honour of being involved in curating a selection of boxing themed film noir movies for Film Noir Fest. The festival is organised by Film Noir UK and is held each autumn in the English seaside town of Weston Super Mare. This year was the third year of the festival and it continues to go from strength to strength. As well as helping to select the movies, I also wrote the screening notes for the festival catalogue. Over the next few weeks, I'm going to reproduce each of those articles here.

 

Here is the second of those articles, originally published in the catalogue for Film Noir Fest 2026. This article contains spoilers.

 

‘What are you going to do? Kill me? Everybody dies.’

Those are the final words of Body and Soul, uttered by fighter Charley Davis (John Garfield) as he leaves the ring and passes the devilish mobster, Roberts (Lloyd Gough). Davis has just defied Roberts’ orders to throw the fight. They could just as easily have been spoken by Garfield himself just a short while later, as he was persecuted by the House Un-American Activities Committee (HUAC) in their Communist witch hunt.

John Garfield was far from alone in being a HUAC target. Body and Soul’s credits read as a virtual who’s who of suspected sympathisers; men and women whose careers and lives were unfairly blighted by the Hollywood Blacklist.

Body and Soul was Garfield’s first movie with his own independent production company, Enterprise Studios, after having parted ways with Warner Brothers. The move gave him freedom over his choice of projects and the option to return to stage work when the right opportunity presented itself. The film was written by Abraham Polonsky, who described it as a ‘folk tale from the Empire city.’

It tells the story of Charley Davis, a poor Jewish kid from New York who discovers that success as a boxer can lead to a life of riches. He also learns that it’s a world of shady characters, temptations and difficult choices. Increasingly drawn to the dark side, the good people in his life fall away; girlfriend Peg (Lilli Palmer), his mother Anna (Anne Revere) and best friend Shorty (Joseph Pevney). Instead, he is surrounded by the likes of classic femme fatale Alice (Hazel Brooks) and the man with whom a deal must be struck in order to get a title shot, the aforementioned Roberts.

The dichotomy of Charley’s possible directions in life are symbolised by the revolving panel in his plush new apartment – on one side is a self-portrait of the virtuous Peg; on the other side a well-stocked bar that epitomises his new lifestyle of capitalist excess. You have to choose one or the other.

At one point, Roberts remarks that he likes ‘fighters better than horses.’ To him they are just commodities, discarded when no longer of value. It is worth noting that even today, boxing managers will refer to their ‘stable’ of fighters.

Charley commits to his deal with the devil and signs to fight champion Ben Chaplin (Canada Lee). Chaplin should be nowhere near a ring, having sustained a brain injury in a previous fight. The fight is agreed on the understanding that Davis will go easy and let it go the distance. But Roberts wants a knockout for the fans, so omits to tell Charley of the arrangement. Charley duly knocks out Chaplin to take the title and is now thoroughly in the grip of Roberts, going against the exhortations of his mother that if he must fight, ‘fight for something, but not for money.’

Davis invites Ben to join his training team, but when Chaplin dies as a result of his injury during a training camp, Charley begins to recognise the error of his ways and the true cost of his choices. But he is in too deep with Roberts. For his next bout, Roberts demands that Charley throws the fight. Davis reluctantly agrees; even wagering his own purse on his opponent to win. This time it is Charley who is assured by Roberts that the deal in place is for him to lose on points.

During the fight, however, Charley at last has an epiphany. But what is it that makes him change course and go for the win? He has gone into the contest intending to lose, despite the disapproval of his mother and Peg, and the shocking death of Ben. Even his local grocer, Shimen, has reminded Charley of how important he is to the Jewish community.

‘While over in Europe, Nazis are killing people like us because of our religion, but here Charley Davis is champion.’

But it is only during the fight when he learns he has been on the receiving end of a double cross and his opponent is actually fighting to knock him out, that Charley decides enough is enough. He does not know how much losing the fight will cost him, but only by winning can he regain his dignity and the respect of those who care about him.

Two endings to the film were shot. Polonsky spoke about how director Robert Rossen’s preferred ending would see Davis killed and ending up ‘with his head in a garbage can.’ Polonsky won out and it is his ending that we see. But is it a happy ending? Will Roberts take revenge? Maybe Rossen’s vision of Davis’s fate follows the final credits. As Orson Welles once said, ‘If you want a happy ending, that depends, of course, on where you stop your story.’

Polonsky was no fan of Rossen, feeling that he ‘had a rotten character.’ He once said of the director that, “You wouldn’t want to be on a desert island with Rossen, because if the two of you didn’t have any food, he might want to have you for lunch tomorrow.’

Polonsky was, however, an admirer of John Garfield, describing him as, ‘the darling of romantic rebels – beautiful, enthusiastic, rich with the know-how of street intelligence. He had passion and a lyrical sadness that was the essence of the role he created as it was created for him.’

Charley Davis’s final stand against evil and corruption was mirrored by Garfield in real life. His refusal to name names at the HUAC hearings ensured he upheld his integrity, but Garfield’s family maintained that his premature death at the age of just 39 was as a direct result of the pressure applied to him from the US government’s Communist witch hunt. His soul remained pure, but it cost him his body.


Recent Posts

See All

Comments


 Powered and secured by Wix

  • Amazon
  • X
  • Facebook
  • Instagram
bottom of page