top of page

The Killers (1946)

Steve Hunt
Nov 5
4 min read

I recently had the honour of being involved in curating a selection of boxing themed film noir movies for Film Noir Fest. The festival is organised by Film Noir UK and is held each autumn in the English seaside town of Weston Super Mare. This year was the third year of the festival and it continues to go from strength to strength. As well as helping to select the movies, I also wrote the screening notes for the festival catalogue. Over the next few weeks, I'm going to reproduce each of those articles here.


Here is the first of those articles, originally published in the catalogue for Film Noir Fest 2026.

This article contains spoilers for an 80 year old movie. Just saying.


The Killers (1946) is about as noir as cinema can get. Eddie Muller has referred to it as ‘the Citizen Kane of crime movies.’ It is based on a short story by Ernest Hemingway, who held a long fascination with boxing; The Killers not being his first story to focus on a fighter. The film version is not so much an adaptation as an extension. The opening of the film follows the narrative of the short story, with the remainder of the movie being wholly original and serving to act as, in the words of the New York Times critic Bosley Crowther, ‘a taut and absorbing explanation of the Hemingway tale.’

In their book, simply titled Film Noir, Paul Duncan and Jurgen Muller argue that Hemingway’s story provided director Robert Siodmak with ‘the material he needed to create a cinematic exploration of guilt, atonement, and predestination.’ Each of those subject matters are classic film noir themes. The idea of predestination looms particularly large.

To his friends in Brentwood, New Jersey, Pete Lund (Burt Lancaster), known as the Swede, was a well-liked, regular guy, who worked at the gas station and had his evening meal at the local diner at the same time every evening. Who could possibly want him dead? Why, when told that two killers were on their way to slay him, did he not try to escape? Why just lie there and accept his bloody fate?

Lund, it transpires, was previously Ole Anderson, a former professional prize fighter whose career was cut short by injury. One punch leads to a broken hand which leads to the end of a fighting career. Follow that with a series of events that felt like conscious choices but now with hindsight seem like an inescapable fateful path leading to death. What is the point of trying to outrun fate?

Ole had a sliding doors moment when his boxing career was cut short. He had another one when he first encountered Kitty Collins (Ava Gardner). There was more chance of his hand injury healing than there was of him recovering from the emotional knockout he received from femme fatale Kitty. In another universe, could things have turned out differently if not for a bad hand and falling under Kitty’s spell?

Actors Burt Lancaster and Wayne Morris had their own entwined sliding doors moments. Born within three months of each other, each served in the US armed forces during WWII and made a career in Hollywood. Morris already had a burgeoning film career when it was cut short by the war, most notably for fans of boxing movies with the title role in Kid Galahad (1937), where he featured alongside Edward G. Robinson, Bette Davis and Humphrey Bogart.

Morris became a Naval flier in 1942 and flew 57 missions. He is credited with helping to sink five enemy ships. For his duty, he was honoured with four Distinguished Flying Crosses and two Air Medals.

In December 1945, Mark Hellinger bought the rights to Hemingway’s The Killers and approached Warner Brothers, who had Morris under contract, about casting their actor, by now a war hero, in the lead role. Warner Brothers wanted $75,000 to loan out Morris, which resulted in Hellinger looking elsewhere and ultimately giving the role to Lancaster.

The Swede (Burt Lancaster) is already under the spell of Kitty Collins (Ava Gardner).
The Swede (Burt Lancaster) is already under the spell of Kitty Collins (Ava Gardner).

Wayne Morris continued to make films, but his once promising career floundered. Other than a role in Stanley Kubrick's Paths of Glory (1957), his post-war filmography comprises mainly of low-budget Westerns. He sadly died of a heart attack at the age of just 45 in September 1959.

When the door closed on The Killers for Wayne Morris, opportunity knocked for Burt Lancaster. The role of the Swede was Lancaster’s feature film debut, and it made him a star. Prior to his own military service, Lancaster had worked as a circus acrobat, but following the critical and commercial success of The Killers, he went on to have a spectacular 45-year career, winning one Academy award for Best Actor and being nominated on another three occasions.

During his flying missions with the Navy, three of Morris’ aircraft were so badly damaged by enemy fire that they had to be scrapped. This was a man who escaped death on more than one occasion, but whose greatest Hollywood opportunity was torpedoed by greedy Warner Brothers executives. Luck, self-determination, or predestination? The Swede would have told you he never had a chance.

Recent Posts

See All

Comments


 Powered and secured by Wix

  • Amazon
  • X
  • Facebook
  • Instagram
bottom of page